Every knee replacement makes a few design choices. None is best for every patient, and for most of them the research finds small or no differences. Your surgeon's experience with a system, your bone quality, your ligaments and your anatomy all shape the choice.
Fixation: cemented or cementless
CementedCementless (press-fit)Hybrid
Cemented implants are fixed with bone cement and are stable immediately. Cementless implants have a porous surface, often 3D-printed titanium, that the bone grows into over the following weeks. Cementless use in the US roughly tripled between 2016 and 2022.17
What the evidence shows
- Randomized trials found no difference in revision or function up to 16 years14
Points of caution
- Two large US registries found no survivorship advantage for cementless; some cementless designs had higher early revision15,16
Clinical detail
- Michigan registry (147,838 TKAs): 5-year cumulative percent revision 3.65% uncemented vs 3.19% cemented (P < 0.0001).15
- Kaiser registry (130,242 TKAs): cementless twin-peg constructs had higher aseptic revision (HR 2.13); spikes-and-keel constructs showed no difference (HR 0.94).16
Ligament handling: CR, PS and medial-congruent
Cruciate-retaining (CR)Posterior-stabilized (PS)Medial-congruent / medial-pivot
The posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) can be kept (cruciate-retaining) or removed and replaced by a post-and-cam mechanism in the implant (posterior-stabilized). Newer "medial-congruent" or "medial-pivot" inserts use a deeper inner side to provide stability with or without the PCL.
What the evidence shows
- A Cochrane review found differences in motion and function too small to matter clinically18
Points of caution
- The choice often depends on the condition of the PCL and the surgeon's training
Clinical detailCochrane (17 RCTs, 1,810 patients): range of motion 2.4 degrees higher and functional KSS 2.3 points higher with PCL sacrifice, judged clinically irrelevant; no difference in pain, WOMAC or complications.18
Bearing: fixed or mobile
Fixed bearingMobile (rotating) bearing
In a fixed-bearing knee the plastic spacer is locked to the tray. In a mobile-bearing knee it can rotate slightly, which was designed to reduce wear. Most US knees are fixed bearing.
What the evidence shows
- A meta-analysis of 74 randomized trials found no advantage for mobile bearings19
Points of caution
- No difference in revision, loosening or knee pain19
The kneecap: resurface or not
ResurfacedRetained (not resurfaced)
The back of the kneecap can be covered with a plastic button or left natural. Practice varies widely between surgeons and countries.
What the evidence shows
- Not resurfacing was linked to more front-of-knee pain and more repeat operations in one meta-analysis20
Points of caution
- Reviews of the meta-analyses found no clear overall winner21
Clinical detail33 RCTs (4,135 TKAs): anterior knee pain OR 1.84 and reoperation OR 1.46 without resurfacing; functional differences did not exceed the MCID.20 Higher reoperation without resurfacing may partly reflect the option of secondary resurfacing.21
What implants are made of
Cobalt-chromeTitaniumOxidized zirconiumPolyethylene
Femoral components are usually cobalt-chromium alloy; some use oxidized zirconium or a ceramic-like coating, which can matter for people with metal sensitivity. Tibial trays are cobalt-chromium or titanium alloy, and cementless versions often use porous titanium. The spacer is ultra-high-molecular-weight polyethylene, often highly cross-linked and sometimes blended with vitamin E to resist oxidation. Ask your surgeon which materials your implant uses.